ERA09LA295

The student pilot's failure to maintain directional control during the landing rollout, which resulted in excessive side loads to the right main landing gear and the separation of the outer main landing gear rib from the right wing.

After the airplane touched down during the student pilot's first solo landing in the composite, fixed tricycle-gear airplane, his flight instructor observed the right wing rise and the nose pitch up slightly, then heard the sound of screeching tires. The right main landing gear subsequently collapsed, and the airplane veered off the left side of the runway. Marks on the runway, along with damage to the landing gear tires, revealed that after touching down, the airplane entered a left skidding turn with only the nose and left main landing gear tires in contact with the runway. Near the end of the turn, the right main landing gear tire deflated when it contacted the runway in a skid. The right main landing gear metal wheel rim then contacted the runway, also in a skid, resulting in excessive side loading to the right main landing gear and separation of the landing gear and outer landing gear rib from the right wing. Winds at the time were calm. An examination of the bonded area between the rib and the vertical webbing of the forward and aft wing spars, and between the rib and the inside surface of the upper wing skin, revealed void areas in the adhesive. However, calculations indicated that the void areas would not have affected the outcome of the event due to the extent of the excessive side forces subjected to the landing gear.

HISTORY OF FLIGHT On May 16, 2009, about 1548 eastern daylight time, a Diamond Aircraft Industries GmbH, DA 40, N323JT, registered to and operated by Waltzing Matilda Training LLC, experienced separation of the right main landing gear during landing at Norwood Memorial Airport (OWD), Norwood, Massachusetts. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed at the time and no flight plan was filed for the 14 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 91 instructional flight. The airplane was substantially damaged and the certificated student pilot, the sole occupant, was not injured. The flight originated at OWD about 1543. The student pilot stated that earlier that day he flew with his certificated flight instructor (CFI) and performed three touch-and-go and two full-stop landings; all were uneventful. His CFI signed him off for his first solo flight, and exited the airplane. The student departed and remained in the traffic pattern for runway 10, turning onto downwind, base and final. While on final approach with the flaps extended, he maintained 75 knots and reduced power to 15 inches manifold pressure when the airplane was over the threshold. He leveled the airplane, then applied aft elevator control input which resulted in a slow decrease in airspeed followed by activation of the stall warning horn. The airplane landed with an indicated airspeed of between 60 and 65 knots with no bouncing, and turned left. He applied right rudder pedal input and right brake to correct but was unsuccessful. The longitudinal axis of the airplane was not aligned with the runway, and while sliding, approaching the edge of the runway, he heard a noise and felt a bump which he thought was the landing gear breaking. After coming to a stop, he notified the tower and then exited the airplane. The student further reported that prior to the accident flight he had performed 39 landings. The student’s CFI stated that he flew with the student earlier that day practicing five normal and abnormal landings which he described as "safe." The weather conditions were "prime" for the student's first solo flight; the wind was straight down the runway at less than 10 knots and the windsock at the approach end of runway indicated no wind. After receiving his endorsement for solo flight, the student started the engine and taxied to runway 10. The CFI elected to stay on the ramp to observe the flight and was located approximately 400 yards away. He reported seeing the airplane on final approach with the flaps down and perceived that the ground speed was good and the pitch attitude was stable. The airplane's first ground contact was located within 500 to 600 feet from the displaced threshold, and there was no float or bounce. The longitudinal axis of the airplane appeared aligned with the runway at touchdown. Approximately 1 to 3 seconds later, he noted that the airplane pitched up and the right wing raised, followed by the sound of screeching tires. He reported the pitch up wasn't, "too steep" and the airplane bounced no more than 1 to 2 feet. The airplane veered off the north side of the runway, and the CFI reported a "very violent skidding turn (brakes alone would not cause such a violent turn." PERSONNEL INFORMATION The student pilot, age 31, was issued a Federal Aviation Administration third class student pilot medical certificate on March 31, 2009, with a limitation to wear corrective lenses. The National Transportation Safety Board Pilot/Operator Aircraft Accident/Incident Report submitted by the operator indicated the student pilot had 17 hours total time, all of which were in the accident make and model airplane. Within the last 90 days and 30 days, he accumulated 8 and 7 hours, respectively. Other than the accident flight, he did not have any logged solo flight time. AIRCRAFT INFORMATION The fixed tricycle gear, composite airplane was manufactured in 2006 by Diamond Aircraft Industries, Inc., as model DA 40, and was designated serial number 40.714. It was equipped by Design Change Advisory MAM 40-123/e with 18 mm thick landing gear struts. Design Change OAM 40-124, also incorporated onto the airplane, specified that smaller main landing gear tire 15x6.0-6 was approved for installation. Review of the maintenance records revealed the airplane was last inspected in accordance with an annual inspection on October 31, 2008. The airplane total time in service at that time was 174.6 hours, and the airplane total time in service at the time of the accident was 226.7 hours. Further review of the maintenance records revealed that, on August 11, 2008, at airplane total time 173.8 hours, a new right main landing gear tire 15X600X6 (actually 15X6.0-6) and new tube 6.00-6 were installed. On February 17, 2009, at airplane total time 272.3 hours, a new right main landing gear tube P/N 6.00-6 was installed. According to the airplane manufacturer, the correct tube P/N based on the installed tire is 15X6.0-6. METEOROLOGICAL INFORMATION A surface observation weather report taken at OWD, at 1553, or approximately 5 minutes after the accident indicated the wind was calm, the visibility was 10 statute miles, and overcast clouds existed at 6,000 feet. The temperature and dew point were 19 and 12 degrees Celsius, respectively, and the altimeter setting was 30.05 inches of mercury. AIRPORT INFORMATION The Norwood Memorial Airport is equipped with two asphalt runways designated 17/35 and 10/28. Runway 10/28 is 3,995 feet long and 75 feet wide. WRECKAGE AND IMPACT INFORMATION Examination of the runway by a representative of the airframe manufacturer with an FAA inspector revealed skid marks corresponding to the left and nose landing gear tires, left of runway centerline beginning approximately 1/3 down the runway. The skid marks from the left and nose landing gears depicted a left arc and were nearly continuous to the north edge of the runway. Two distinct skid marks associated with the right main landing gear were noted at the end of the skid marks near the north edge of the runway. A gouge in the runway surface associated with the right main landing gear wheel skid mark was noted; the skid marks associated with the right main landing gear were serpentine like. The total length of the skid marks were measured and found to be 247 feet. The airplane came to rest upright on grass off the north side of the runway with the right main landing gear nearly separated. Examination of the airplane by a representative of the airframe manufacturer with FAA oversight revealed that the right main landing gear remained attached only by brake hoses. A spanwise crack was noted in the upper wing skin of the right wing from the wing root outboard. Inspection of the right main landing gear wheel assembly revealed the wheel was broken in large pieces almost to the center where the two halves join. The outboard rim was scarred and abraded by the runway surface. The right main landing gear tire (15x6.0-6) was flat and exhibited sidewall damage appearing as cuts. There were no wear or skid marks on the tread surface. The inner tube had a 5 inch long split along it’s inside center line. The wheel fairing was severely damaged. Inspection of the right wing revealed the outer main landing gear rib part number (P/N) D41-5313-52-00_2-00 with attached main landing gear leg was torn out of the right wing center section. The aluminum retaining plate P/N D41-3213-01-51, which secured the right main landing gear in place, showed bending damage in the forward 1/3 of its length. The right main landing gear leg P/N D41-3213-12-50 was bent inward approximately 7 degrees at the lower radius, and approximately 2 degrees about the vertical axis. The right outer main landing gear rib was retained for further examination. Inspection of the left main landing gear tire revealed uneven wear (flat-spotting) and reduction of sidewall to tread radius on ¼ of the circumference of the tire. Indications